Faced with the scale of the online reputation phenomenon, many hospitality professionals feel helpless and powerless, at the mercy of public opinion. What are the ways to respond?
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Aurélie Klein, lawyer, Coblence & Associates law firm
|
|
Accept criticism, reject abuse, and avoid... "bad buzz"
Building your reputation on the Internet also means taking the risk, and accepting, of exposing yourself to criticism.
Being free to express oneself does not mean that one can say anything and everything: While freedom of expression remains the norm, the abuse of the right to criticize is punishable.
However, the line between free criticism and opinions that may be condemned on a civil or criminal level is not always easy to define, especially since the judge, in his assessment, will most often take into account the status of the author of the disputed opinion (simple consumer or professional journalist) by favouring, for the former, freedom of expression.
This is why professionals must be supported and advised in order to opt for a graduated response and thereby avoid the so-called "Streisand effect", an internet phenomenon which manifests itself by a considerable increase in the dissemination of content that was initially sought to be censored.
What "toolbox" is available for professionals?
The practice of fake reviews constitutes an unfair and misleading commercial practice within the meaning of Articles L. 120-1 and 121-1 of the Consumer Code, namely a commercial practice contrary to the requirements of professional diligence and which alters, or is likely to alter in a substantial way, the economic behavior of the normally informed and reasonably attentive and circumspect consumer.
It is on this basis that the Paris High Court on June 20, 2014, fined a company managing a review site 7.000 euros and its manager 3.000 euros for writing and publishing false consumer reviews.
Defamatory or insulting opinions may be removed on the basis of the law of July 29, 1881 on the freedom of the press, it being specified that defamation corresponds to the allegation or imputation of a specific and unproven fact, which damages the honor or the reputation of a specific or identifiable natural or legal person, and that insult refers to any outrageous expression, terms of contempt or invective which does not contain the imputation of any fact.
However, in both cases, it will be necessary to act quickly, as the repression of press offences is subject to an extremely short statute of limitations of three months from the date of publication.
Disparaging opinions which, unlike defamation and insult, only concern a product or service, may, for their part, be sanctioned on the basis of Article 1382 of the Civil Code.
Obtaining the removal of an illegal review from the hosting provider
To have an illegal opinion posted on the internet removed, the first step is to report this content to the site that is relaying it by using the provisions of the law of June 21, 2004 for confidence in the digital economy.
This law, while establishing the principle of reduced and "a posteriori" liability for hosting providers, has instituted a procedure for notifying hosting providers of illegal content.
Thus, while hosting providers are not subject to a general obligation to monitor the content they store, they may be held liable if, from the moment they became aware of its illegal nature, they did not act promptly to remove it.
It should be noted, however, that the victim must scrupulously observe the rigorous formalities imposed by law.
Professionals will therefore need to ensure they seek assistance in such procedures, especially since the misuse of sending a notification to remove illegal content is punishable by one year of imprisonment and a fine of 15.000 euros.
Identify the author of the contributions
In order to facilitate the identification of the perpetrators of an offence, the law on confidence in the digital economy requires internet service providers and hosting providers to retain data "that may allow the identification of anyone who contributed to the creation of the content or one of the contents of the services they provide".
The judicial authority can therefore request the communication of this data either at the request of a third party (via an application for interim relief or an order on request), or in the context of a judicial investigation carried out by the police or gendarmerie services.
Towards a new legal framework?
Axelle Lemaire's bill "for a digital Republic", in its article 21, provides for a reinforced obligation of information on the responsibility of those in charge of consumer review platforms, in particular on the existence or not of a verification of reviews and where applicable the modalities of such control.
| Aurélie Klein and Claire Cambernon (Lawyers, Coblence & Associés Law Firm) |
Monday, December 7, 2015 With the kind permission of the Journal de l'Hôtellerie


